When pulled over by police, you’ve not committed a crime or a traffic infraction, you have to show ID at the request of police.

The claim that you must show ID to police when stopped, even if you have not committed a crime or traffic infraction, is only partially accurate and depends heavily on jurisdiction and context. Most U.S. states have "stop and identify" laws that require individuals to identify themselves under certain conditions, often tied to reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, but not universally in all encounters. When driving, showing ID is generally mandatory due to vehicle regulations. However, for pedestrians or those not driving, many states do not require ID unless police have reasonable suspicion or probable cause. The sources, while not from fully trusted outlets, consistently indicate that the obligation to show ID is conditional rather than absolute, varying by state and situation. Therefore, the claim is an oversimplification and lacks nuance regarding the legal thresholds that trigger the duty to identify oneself.