When pulled over by police, you’ve not committed a crime or a traffic infraction, you have to show ID at the request of police.

The claim that you must show ID to police when stopped despite not having committed a crime or traffic infraction is only partially accurate and depends heavily on jurisdiction and context. Most U.S. states have "stop and identify" laws requiring individuals to identify themselves if police have reasonable suspicion of involvement in a crime, but this does not universally apply to all stops or to situations where no suspicion exists. Drivers generally must show ID when operating a vehicle, but pedestrians or those not suspected of wrongdoing often have no legal obligation to provide ID. The sources, though not from major trusted outlets, consistently indicate that the requirement to show ID is conditional, not absolute, and varies by state law and the nature of the police encounter.